MANNAFEST

Hebrew Roots · letter 21 of 22

Shin

The three-armed letter — worn on doorposts, shaped by priests' hands, and split down the middle by scholars.

Sounds like

š / ś

Its number

300

Its name means

Disputed along with the sign. If the old name was shinn it meant “tooth”; if it was shamsh it meant “sun.” The field has not settled it, and neither reading can be called the answer.

Final form

none

Shin is the letter scholars argue about most. Was the original sign a row of teeth, or the sun with its rays? The name pulls one way, the oldest shapes have been read both ways, and after a hundred years the question is still open. Two of the twenty-two signs are like this. This is one.

It is also the letter with a dot problem. Put the dot over the right arm and the letter says sh: shalom, shema, Shaddai. Move the dot to the left arm and the same letter says s. The name Israel has it that way — the second letter of Yisraʾel is this letter, pronounced s. One sign, two sounds, and before the scribes added the dots a reader simply knew which one the word wanted.

No letter in the alphabet carries more devotional weight than this one — on doorposts, in the priests' hands, in the shape of a city's hills. That is exactly why the labels matter here more than anywhere else. The picture tells you where the shape and sound came from. It does not tell you what words mean. Everything beyond that lives in the readings band below, named as readings.

Where Scripture itself plays with this letter

Everything in this band is checkable — something the biblical text or the manuscripts that carry it demonstrably do with this letter.

One letter, two sounds — and Psalm 119 uses both

Psalm 119's shin stanza runs from verse 161 to verse 168, and its very first word is a small joke on the dot. “Princes have persecuted me without a cause” — sarim, with the dot on the left, pronounced s. The stanza named for shin opens on sin.

Both sounds sit inside the same twenty-two letters. The alphabet poems count the letter, not the sound, which is a quiet piece of evidence that the two sounds were felt to be one letter long before anybody wrote a dot on it.

Shemaʿ — “Hear, O Israel”

“Hear, O Israel: Jehovah our God, Jehovah is one.” The sentence observant Jews have said morning and evening for well over two thousand years opens with this letter, and the name Israel carries it too — with the dot on the other side.

Jesus was asked which commandment was first of all, and he answered by quoting this verse before anything else.

Two more things about this one verse, both of which belong to other rooms: the ayin that ends shemaʿ is written oversized in the manuscripts, and so is the dalet that ends ʾechad, “one.”

The blessing the priests were told to say

“Jehovah bless thee, and keep thee: Jehovah make his face to shine upon thee, and be gracious unto thee: Jehovah lift up his countenance upon thee, and give thee peace.”

Three lines, given by name to Aaron and his sons, and each line longer than the one before it. The last word of the last line is shalom.

The way the priests hold their hands while saying it, and what tradition has read into that shape, is in the readings band below — where it belongs, because the hand position is a practice, not a text.

Shalom is a bigger word than “peace”

English “peace” mostly means the absence of trouble. Shalom means the presence of wholeness: things intact, accounts settled, a body healthy, a city safe, a person complete. You can ask after someone's shalom the way English asks how they are.

That is why “Pray for the peace of Jerusalem” is not a request for quiet, and why “Prince of Peace” is not a title about calm. It is about everything being put right.

Words that begin here

How readers have meditated on this letter

What follows is devotional reading — meaning laid on top of the sign by readers who loved it, not a fact about what Hebrew words mean. It is carried here because it is old, beautiful, and genuinely part of how this letter has been received. It is kept behind this door so nobody mistakes it for grammar.

The letter on the doorposta devotional reading

Walk past a Jewish home and you may see a small case fixed at an angle to the doorframe, with a single Hebrew letter on the outside of it: shin. Inside is a tiny scroll carrying the words of Deuteronomy 6, including the command to write these words on the doorposts of your house. The box worn on the head in prayer carries the letter too, embossed on both sides — with three arms on one side and four on the other.

The practice is real and living. The reading of the letter — that it stands for Shaddai, the Almighty, so that the house is marked by his name — is Jewish tradition attached to the sign. Every doorpost wearing this letter is wearing a tradition, not a translation.

Read this way by: Jewish practice (the mezuzah of Deuteronomy 6:9 and the tefillin), with the traditional reading of the letter as standing for Shaddai

The priests' handsa devotional reading

When the kohanim — descendants of Aaron — pronounce the blessing of Numbers 6 over a congregation, they raise their hands and spread the fingers in a particular way: thumbs together, a gap between the second and third fingers on each hand, so that the hands together make a three-part shape. Tradition reads that shape as the letter shin, standing for Shaddai — the Almighty blessing his people through their hands.

This is the most widely recognized hand position in the world and almost nobody knows why. Leonard Nimoy, raised in an Orthodox Jewish home, watched the priests do it as a boy from behind his father's covering hands, never forgot it, and years later gave it to Mr Spock as the Vulcan salute. He told the story often and freely.

The blessing is Scripture. The hand shape is a practice; reading the letter in it is tradition — and it is the single most-travelled fact about any Hebrew letter.

Read this way by: Jewish priestly practice (birkat kohanim); the Star Trek connection is Leonard Nimoy's own account of where the Vulcan salute came from

Three arms, three fathersa devotional reading

Rabbinic tradition reads shin's three arms as Abraham, Isaac and Jacob — the three patriarchs, distinct and rising out of one root. The four-armed shin on the head-box of the tefillin has its own traditional readings alongside it.

A reading of a letterform, offered on its own terms as Jewish tradition. The square-script shape it reads is itself relatively late; the letter did not always have three neat arms.

Read this way by: Rabbinic tradition on the letterform

The city that wears the lettera devotional reading

Look at a relief map of Jerusalem and three valleys — the Hinnom, the Tyropoeon and the Kidron — come together south of the old city in a shape people have long said traces a shin. Readers who love this put it next to Deuteronomy's promise about “the place which Jehovah your God shall choose out of all your tribes, to put his name there”: the city marked with the letter of the Name.

This is a reading of a map, taught widely in both Jewish and Christian circles, and it is a reading — not a claim the text makes and not a fact about the letter. Held as a reflection, it is a striking one.

Read this way by: A widely taught modern devotional reading; the promise it is laid beside is Deuteronomy 12:5

Where this letter leads

Sources: Alan H. Gardiner, “The Egyptian Origin of the Semitic Alphabet,” Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 3 (1916) · Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar, ed. Kautzsch, tr. Cowley (Oxford, 1910), §5 — the alphabet and the shin/sin dot · Brown-Driver-Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (1906) · Benjamin Sass, The Genesis of the Alphabet (1988); Gordon J. Hamilton, The Origins of the West Semitic Alphabet in Egyptian Scripts (2006) — cited, not quoted, on the tooth/sun dispute · C. D. Ginsburg, Introduction to the Massoretico-Critical Edition of the Hebrew Bible (London, 1897) · C. H. Spurgeon, The Treasury of David, on Psalm 119:161-168 Every cited work — the sources registry →